Urban Melbourne

Observe. Design. Build. Live.

Advertisement

Standing on the outside looking in...

First off today an apology to the young RMIT student to which the two images below belong.  Currently on display within level ten of the RMIT Design Hub building, the scheme below is one of many works conceived by this years crop of students.  With no visible student name of number, we can't credit this design to any particular student...so if any information is forwarded, Urban Melbourne will be happy to publish the details.

On the student creation, it's envisaged as an integrated transport hub catering principally toward the movement of freight.  Air, sea, rail and road transport options are incorporated into the design located on the current Toll Automotive dock which meets Williamstown Road.  With an associated hotel, office building and public transport station, it surely is a grand design.  

Now Urban Melbourne wouldn't be so daft as to critique this particular design, yet it does provide a visual context as to the article that will follow. 

As recently as July media reports suggested the possibility of an airport being built within Melbourne's Docklands area. According to the Herald Sun the suitably named Outer Suburban/Interface Services and Development Committee, made up of three Liberal and two Labor MPs, urged the Victorian Government to consider a city airport (in many ways quite similar to London City Airport) which would "Better service low-cost segments of the aviation market."  Further "The committee believes that a Melbourne City Airport could be a useful ... particularly for commuter-type domestic flights and short-haul international flights such as to New Zealand." 

The committee report stated "Such an airport could be a useful addition as part of a comprehensive brownfield redevelopment area near the centre of Melbourne, such as Docklands," said the report, which was handed down during June.

Given the stupendous size and expense of such a venture, what would be the inhibiting factors for this city airport....aside from common sense?

  • The Westgate and Bolte Bridges, built obstacles in any such venture.  With minimum separation required the alignment and location of any runway is surely compromised.
  • Melbourne's variable winds.  Although the prevailing north/south winds would dictate runway alignment, a single runway would unlikely be operational for periods of time
  • Two efficient existing airports with a third major airport mooted on suburban Melbourne's south eastern fringe.
  • The ground swell of public opinion demanding a dedicated rail line to Melbourne Airport
  • Encroaching populous as Fishermans Bend is progressively developed, not to mention existing areas 
  • Aircraft noise, and many more

So the Docklands airport notion has been dispelled as the random musings of a committee justifying their existence.  Now for the crux of the article, rather than ideas of folly would it not be more appropriate to invest in a rail link to Melbourne Airport, but also further study the eventual relocation of the Port of Melbourne?

This is very much a long term stance yet the initial planning has been done.  The Port of Hastings has already been earmarked as a major future container port, as has a section of land between Point Wilson and Werribee South.  At what point would common sense suggest Avalon as a contender where Avalon Airport owner Linfox Group has for a long period of time trumpeted their desire to turn the facility into a freight hub amalgamating rail, air and sea movements.  

Throw in pending developments such as Salta Group's inland ports at Altona and Lyndhurst which are essentially integrated freight logistics, container handling, storage and distribution centres along with the mooted south eastern airport and a picture is starting to emerge of a future outer metropolitan arc of infrastructure designed to handle Melbourne ever burgeoning freight movements.  At either end of this arc may just be Melbourne's two international ports.

Could the way forward be a model where cumbersome shipping, freight and associated industry are one the urban periphery - on the outside looking in?  This is of course diametrically opposed to the current model where Port of Melbourne (and the notion of a city airport) are at the heart of Melbourne, causing some metaphorical heartburn I might add.  

Consider this - amazingly enough the image above will one day be dominated by high density housing and commercial use, in effect creating a megatropolis from Footscray to Fishermans Bend.  Gone will be the Port of Melbourne, in its place swathes of new development land which could soak up Melbourne's burgeoning population over not years but decades.  Port Melbourne, Docklands, Southbank, Fishermans Bend and E-gate are examples of existing and future examples of mixed purpose development over what was formerly industrial land in order to assist an expanding central Melbourne.

Freight would be efficiently distributed to transport centres without having to traverse inner urban areas, a larger percentage of the population would live closer to Melbourne's CBD allowing for decreased use of private vehicles and a decrease in inner Melbourne truck journeys alleviating to a degree strains on current road infrastructure.  More people living within a certain radius of the CBD suggests that public transport would benefit due to economies of scale involved - high frequency services for a high density population...and so I could continue on and on.

Now some will suggest this is pie in the sky material, but certainly not as whimsical as an airport based within the City of Melbourne.  The initial steps in identifying the long term shift of Port of Melbourne have been taken, whether it occurs in our lifetime is another question.

Rate this article: 
Average: 5 (4 votes)

Comments

Modernaux's picture

Remember that Fishermans Bend had an operational runway some time ago for Hawker de Havilland (now Boeing).

http://www.lib.unimelb.edu.au/collections/maps/historical/1945melb/848b4...
http://www.boeing.com.au/Boeing-In-Australia/History

Development & Planning

Thursday, April 24, 2014 - 06:13
Touched upon briefly in an earlier article highlighting the roughly 5000 new hotel rooms slated for Melbourne , it seems the lid is about to be lifted on QT Hotel and Residences Melbourne. The residential component of the development has an active website which like all other project websites, extols...

Policy, Culture & Opinion

Friday, April 11, 2014 - 12:00
Height is perhaps the most contentious of all issues when discussing new building proposals. Maybe because it is readily quantifiable relative to the surroundings, or because fear of height has become a default response to any new development, it is often debated as a singular issue. Many ignore the other...

Advertisement

Visual Melbourne

Wednesday, April 2, 2014 - 13:56
Do you have an Instagram account? Do you like taking photos of buildings? Would you like to win a $500 voucher to dine on some top nosh? Well, follow @Elenberg_fraser on Instagram, take original photos of EF designed buildings, tag the EF Instagram account in your photo and use the...

Transport & Design

Monday, April 21, 2014 - 09:41
As previously reported , the much loved Melbourne restaurant The Stokehouse on the St Kilda foreshore was burnt to the ground in a fire in January. Since then a new temporary ‘pop up’ structure has been assembled to continue the service of fine food. The speed with which this temporary...

Sustainability & Environment

Image © tensile.com.au
Thursday, April 3, 2014 - 12:05
Last week the Australian arm of prominent global engineering firm Meinhardt released a white paper titled 'How Far Are We From Truly Green Façades?' via their Practical Imagination platform. The white paper delves into the issues currently surrounding the advancement of green facades which in turn allows the practice to...